Saturday, January 19, 2013


You may know Joanna of Castile's little sister better; Catherine of Aragon, Henry the Eighth’s first wife. Joanna and Catherine were both capable, powerful and intelligent monarchs who fell victim to contemporary attitudes towards women. 

Cromwell said of Catherine: "If not for her sex, she could have defied all the heroes of History." Joanna had just as strong a character - and yet she became known to history as Juana La Loca - Crazy Jo.

She was the daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain. Like her sisters, she was groomed from birth to make a good marriage and thus expand her parent’s sphere of influence.  Her first lessons were French, needlework music and dancing, everything required to make her a good medieval wife.

While still an infant she was betrothed to Philip of Flanders, Duke of Burgundy and son of the Holy Roman Emperor Maximillian. 

She did not need meet her future husband until she was sent to Flanders in 1496, when she was seventeen. 

But for an arranged marriage, it was extraordinarily successful; the two fell in love at first sight.

Philip’s nickname was ‘Philip the Handsome’ and he apparently thought blue eyed strawberry blonde princess was easy on the eye also; he insisted they get consummate the marriage almost as soon as she got off the ship.  

Unfortunately, the prince and his Spanish princess did not live happily ever after; this was the fifteenth century, after all, and Philip did not see marriage as an impediment to sleeping with the rest of the court. 

Juana proved jealous and possessive; it was alleged that she attacked one of his mistresses, cutting off her hair. In those days this was shocking behavior; a royal queen was supposed to turn a blind eye. Juana's temperament was quite contrary.

In 1502, following the deaths of her brother, her sister and her nephew, Juana became heiress to the throne of Castile.

But when her mother, the queen, died two years later the grandees of Castile were slow to proclaim Juana their new regent. It seems that after years of living in his wife's shadow her father, Ferdinand, coveted the throne for himself.  

He minted Castilian coins in the name of "Ferdinand and Juana, King and Queen of Castile, Léon and Aragon," and then persuaded the Cortes that Juana was too mentally unstable to govern.

Philip, however, minted his own coins in the name of "Philip and Joanna, King and Queen of Castile, Léon and Archdukes of Austria.”

Late in 1505 Philip and Juana arrived in Castile and the country was thrown into turmoil. Philip and Ferdinand tried to solve the impasse by intriguing with each other, signing an agreement that Juana's mental instability made her incapable of ruling and promising to exclude her from future government.

But all Philip’s intriguing came to end when he died suddenly of typhoid; some historians have suggested that Ferdinand had him poisoned. 

With the country riven with plague and famine Juana was unable to secure the funds to protect her position. Ferdinand took power, confining Juana to the Santa Clara convent in Tordesillas near Valladolid. He claimed she was mad and therefore unfit to accept the crown.

If Juana was not mentally ill before being locked away, her mental state was fractured by her confinement. 

Even after her father's death in 1517 Juana’s position did not improve. 

As soon as her son, Charles, had obtained from her the necessary authorization to assume the throne he confirmed that her lonely confinement would continue.

Her youngest daughter, Catalina, lived with her at Tordesillas for sixteen years, but in 1625, she was kidnapped and married off to King Juan III of Portugal leaving Juana bereft. 

Juana lived on another thirty years, dying at the great age, for those times, of 76. She was buried beside her husband Philip in the Royal Chapel at Granada, across from the tombs of her parents Ferdinand and Isabella.  
Was La Loca really mad?
Did she really spend nights by a moldy coffin talking to the corpse of her dead husband - as rumour would have it? 

Or was she rather a political pawn, betrayed by her father, her husband and her son, who exaggerated her symptoms for political gain? 

Most historians now agree that Juana suffered severe clinical depression or even a bipolar disorder inherited through the family line, perhaps consequent to incestuous marriage practices. But just how severe her symptoms were - and how ruthlessly she was manipulated by those around her - we shall never really now. 

The mother of two emperors and four queens she spent much of her life shut away in solitude. Of all the great Spanish queens, her story is perhaps the most tragic.

See a pictorial storyboard of Colin Falconer's novel 'HAREM' - the story of Suleiman the Magnificent and his queen, Roxelana HERE and more history from Colin Falconer at
From History and Women

1 comment:

Sue Bursztynski said...

Doesn't surprise me about Ferdinand. He left Catherine to suffer between her marriages to Arthur and Henry. That Scrooge Henry VII didn't see why he should support her and neither did her own father. So Ferdinand's treatment of his other daughter is about typical. What a family!